Netflix’s Top 10 is being taken over by these two wild real-life crime stories

Netflix subscribers can’t seem to get enough of shocking real-life crime stories right now, and the platform’s top 10 daily movie list is proof. Two chilling true-crime dramatizations, Hoax: The Kidnapping of Sherri Papini and Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard, are currently dominating Netflix. They’re pulling in attention for their disturbing, headline-making real-world cases!

Both films are based on true events that already captivated the public years ago, but their arrival (or renewed surge) on Netflix has brought the stories back into the spotlight. Now, they’re sparking fresh conversations, online debates, and renewed fascination with two of the most bizarre crimes in recent memory.

According to Netflix’s current top 10 daily data in the U.S., both titles are ranking in the upper half of the chart. So what exactly makes these two movies so gripping?

A fake kidnapping that fooled the nation: Hoax: The Kidnapping of Sherri Papini

One of the films taking over Netflix is Hoax: The Kidnapping of Sherri Papini. It’s based on the infamous 2016 disappearance of Sherri Papini, a California mother whose case triggered a nationwide search.

At the time, Papini vanished while allegedly jogging near her home in Redding, California. Her phone and earbuds were found abandoned, and the story quickly escalated into a national mystery. For weeks, authorities and the public believed she had been abducted.

Then, three weeks later, Papini reappeared on Thanksgiving Day. She was injured and claimed she had been kidnapped and tortured by two women. Her emotional return made headlines across the country and turned her into a sympathetic figure overnight. But the story didn’t hold up.

Years later, investigators uncovered major inconsistencies in her account. DNA evidence eventually pointed to an ex-boyfriend, and federal authorities concluded that Papini had actually been staying with him voluntarily during her disappearance. She later pleaded guilty to making false statements and mail fraud tied to the hoax.

The real-life case became one of the most widely discussed “false kidnapping” scandals in modern U.S. history, and the dramatization shows how a seemingly tragic disappearance transformed into a criminal deception that shocked the public.

Jaime King stars in the leading role as Sherri Papini. Also in the cast are Matt Hamilton, Josh Collins, Lossen Chambers, and Jill Teed.

A murdered mother and a stolen newborn: Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard

The second film in Netflix’s top 10 is Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard, a dramatization of another real-life case that stunned Texas and the broader true-crime community.

The story follows Heidi Broussard, a young mother who disappeared in December 2019 shortly after giving birth to her newborn daughter. What initially looked like a missing-person case quickly escalated into something far darker. Authorities soon focused their investigation on someone extremely close to her. That person was her longtime friend Magen Fieramusca.

According to the real case, Fieramusca had allegedly been pretending to be pregnant at the same time as Broussard and maintained a fabricated pregnancy for months while inserting herself into Broussard’s life. The friendship, which once appeared supportive and close, became the center of suspicion.

When Broussard vanished along with her newborn, investigators ultimately uncovered a devastating truth. She had been murdered, and her baby had been taken in an attempt to pass the child off as Fieramusca’s own. The case horrified the public not just because of the murder itself, but because of the betrayal at its core.

Anna Hopkins takes on the lead role of Heidi Broussard in the film on Netflix, with Emily Osment as Magen Fieramusca. The cast also includes Ian Lake, Jamie Spilchuk, Sabryn Rock, Candice Lidstone, Paulino Nunes, Sonia Dhillon Tully, Ashton Cressman, and Jolanta Mojsej.

With both Hoax: The Kidnapping of Sherri Papini and Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard holding spots on Netflix’s top 10, it’s clear that true crime continues to dominate viewer attention.

Whether it’s a fabricated kidnapping that fooled investigators or a friendship that ended in tragedy and theft, these stories tap into something deeply unsettling. That’s how easily trust can be broken and how far deception can go before it’s uncovered.