There’s no such thing as a ‘guilty pleasure’. Or at least, that’s what I used to think before I started watching Harlan Coben shows.
As one of the world’s most successful crime writers, Coben has written more than 35 novels with sales exceeding 90 million copies globally. That’s a whole lot of crime.
These days, it’s hard to imagine a time when airport bookshops weren’t stacked with piles of getaway reads by Coben, and the same is now true of the TV landscape as well.
Twists, cliffhangers and flashback wigs abound in the multiple Harlan Coben adaptations that are now available to watch on the small screen, channeling every ludicrous turn of the source material with wild abandon.
It’s not just Coben’s fellow Americans who revel in the escape his writing provides. Multiple stories of his have been adapted in other countries across a range of languages, which just goes to show that guilty pleasures such as these are actually a universal phenomenon.
Murder, revenge and high campery are just some of the ingredients that make a good Harlan Coben adaptation, even if you might not always associate that word with the TV shows that his writing has inspired.
As such, it’s hard to rank them. Like one guilty pleasure and you’ll like them all. Yet, some Harlan Coben shows are better than others, it’s true. So without further ado, here’s our ranking of every single one, ranging from terrible to just preposterously bad.
17. Lazarus (2025)
More left-field than most, Lazarus had the potential to be a top-tier Coben series. Not only was this one written for TV specifically, it also introduced supernatural elements that deviated from the norm. Throw in superstars like Sam Claflin and Bill Nighy and it was all really promising, which makes the dreadful… well, everything, even more disappointing. Without Coben’s usual camp to level things out, the preposterous mystery was just borderline tedious. This is one Lazarus we hope doesn’t get resurrected anytime soon.
16. Gone for Good (2021)
Guillaume Lucchesi (Finnegan Oldfield) spends his summers at his family estate on the French Riviera, which is great until his girlfriend and older brother are murdered there in front of him. 10 years on, Guillaume’s fiancée vanishes around the same time as his mother’s funeral. The poor guy can’t catch a break, and neither can we, because this French adaptation falters with repetitive flashbacks and bland characterisation. Oldfield is innocent though, acting-wise. I won’t spoil it if his character is innocent too.
15. The Five (2016)
Released in the wilderness before Coben’s prolific deal with Netflix, The Five is a little shoddier than most of the adaptations that followed. The story, about four childhood friends who reunite in search of a boy who went missing in the ’90s, doesn’t gel because the chemistry these so-called friends share doesn’t gel either. Running 10 episodes in total, The Five is about five episodes too long, although it is rather watchable, still.
14. Just One Look (2025)
Set in Warsaw, Poland, Just One Look follows Greta (Maria Dębska) whose life is upended when her husband disappears at the same time an old suspect photo of him surfaces. Pacier than usual, this adaptation jumps between Greta’s journey and prosecutor Borys Gajewicz (Mirosław Zbrojewicz), who’s searching for his missing daughter after she shows up in the same photo. The final twist is a doozy, if not entirely unexpected for anyone already familiar with Coben’s unhinged proclivities.
13. Missing You (2025)
This is a toughie. On one hand, we have to commend any show that puts the spotlight on Slow Horses standout Rosalind Eleazar, plus the unexpected horror elements are disturbingly effective. What’s disappointing, however, is that the rare, female-led Coben adaptation ends up being one where the detective is obsessed with her fiancé who cruelly abandoned her 11 years prior. Suspenseful at points and dull at others, this is distinctly mid-tier Coben.
12. Hold Tight (2022)
Hold Tight broke formula by telling a story that connects with another adaptation, making this an unofficial sequel to The Woods. Pawel (Grzegorz Damięcki), Laura (Agnieszka Grochowska) and Kaja (Agata Labno) from that earlier show all appear again, but you can still enjoy Hold Tight on its own terms as the focus is on Anna (Magdalena Boczarska) whose son Adam (Krzysztof Oleksyn) disappears after their friend dies. Not the best adaptation, but not the worst either.
11. Shelter (2023)
Unlike other Coben adaptations, Prime Video’s Shelter is told through the eyes of teenagers instead of the usual middle-class family we’ve come to expect from his work. Otherwise, this is typical Coben fare. The story follows Mickey Bolitar (Jaden Michael) who becomes entangled in the mysterious disappearance of a student at his school following the death of his father. A young cast mix up the Coben formula, although some of the twists border on tasteless this time around, and not even a final cliffhanger could save the show from cancellation.
10. I Will Find You (2026)
Netflix’s newest Coben adaptation is also one of its starriest. Sam Worthington, Britt Lower, Milo Ventimiglia and Clancy Brown are just a few of the big names that appear in this story of a man who’s wrongfully imprisoned for murdering his son, only to discover that his child might still be alive. I Will Find You ticks off all the usual boxes, but an added prison break element, not to mention the sheer charisma of this cast, elevates it above other preposterous Coben thrillers of the same ilk.
9. Run Away (2026)
Netflix knows that New Year’s Day is the best day for a new Harlan Coben drop because that’s the one day of the year we want to think the least. Thankfully, Run Away didn’t demand a lot of thinking upon its release this year. As is so often the case, this one follows a guy played by James Nesbitt who’s searching for a missing person. It’s what happens next that makes this worth watching though, because the plot ends up far more outrageous than that simple log line suggests.
8. Caught (2025)
Caught is unique for being the first Latin American adaptation of Harlan’s work, but it’s still undeniably a Coben story. Set in Bariloche, Argentina, Caught follows investigative journalist Ema Garay (Soledad Villamil) who fights tirelessly to catch criminals who have evaded justice. But when her latest case points the finger at a close friend, Garay must look deeper to uncover the truth. Get caught up in one of the most consistent Coben adaptations to date.
7. Safe (2018)
Dexter star Michael C Hall takes the lead here as Tom Delaney, a pediatric surgeon who moves his daughters into a British gated community following the death of his wife. When one goes missing with her boyfriend, Delaney takes matters into his own hands, only to discover that British suburbia is kind of messed up, much like American suburbia. Safe is quintessential Coben in many ways, except some of his most ridiculous tendencies are reigned in so stuff like plot can be focused on instead.
6. The Woods (2020)
Before Just One Look, Netflix’s first Polish adaptation of Coben’s work was a success, even if the show wasn’t watched as widely as some of its English-language counterparts. Prosecutor Paweł Kopiński (Grzegorz Damięcki) is summoned when a murder connects him to a deadly summer camp incident in 1994, which resulted in the disappearance of his sister. Why this one works so well is because the flashback sequences give us a fully realised story in their own right, rather than the usual timeline tomfoolery which puts the cast in bad wigs and calls it a day.
5. Fool Me Once (2024)
You’ve seen one Coben mystery, you’ve seen a hundred Coben mysteries, except Fool Me Once is a bit more special than that. Along with regular collaborator Richard Armitage, this story of a woman who doesn’t believe her husband is really dead stars Michelle Keegan and British royalty Joanna Lumley as the mother-in-law. That instantly bumps Fool Me Once up six places automatically on this list, and that’s without going into the scene-stealing performance from Adeel Akhtar in a cast full of scene-stealers.
4. No Second Chance (2015)
After a brutal attack, a doctor named Alice wakes up a week later to find that her husband has been murdered and her baby is missing. Moving the action from the US to France already helps set this one apart, and what works even better is how No Second Chance switches the protagonist’s gender. Missing daughter thrillers are a dime a dozen at this point, but few take the viewpoint of the mother. Special shout out to actor Hippolyte Girardot, who plays a grouchier than usual detective working the case named Cyril Tessier.
3. Stay Close (2021)
Stay Close is a puzzle box that throws three seemingly random people together, gradually intertwining their lives as they connect to an unsolved case. Coben regulars Richard Armitage and James Nesbitt play a photographer and detective, while crime drama queen Cush Jumbo is cast as a former exotic dancer who’s now raising three kids. This one’s a lot grislier than most, as exemplified by two musical theatre-loving assassins, Barbie (Poppy Gilbert) and Ken (Hyoie O’Grady), who kill someone with a pneumatic drill, but not before they perform a freaky synchronised dance to Radiohead’s classic song Creep.
2. The Innocent (2021)
Easily the best non-English-language Coben thriller, the Spanish adaptation of The Innocent follows law school student Mateo Vidal (Mario Casas) who goes to prison for accidental manslaughter. Four years later, Mateo is released only to discover his wife has gone missing. So far, so Coben. But this Barcelona-set thriller is operating at a higher level than most of the others on this list, sticking the landing in ways that these adaptations so rarely manage.
1. The Stranger (2020)
Not content with just one or two mysteries, The Stranger weaves in a bunch when a nameless young woman (Hannah John-Kamen) goes around telling life-changing secrets in a local community. The show itself won’t exactly change your life, but it might just change your mind if you’ve been anti-Coben up until this point. There’s just something so deliciously addictive about how everything comes together, even if this is yet another Richard Armitage-fronted thriller. The world wasn’t the same after this show, quite literally, but that’s just because COVID hit a couple months later.
Check out more of our Drama coverage or visit our TV Guide and Streaming Guide to find out what’s on. For more TV recommendations and reviews listen to The Radio Times Podcast.
